‘Silver Trauma’ or Trauma in older people
Presented by: Dr Iain Wilkinson
Faculty: Pam Trangmar, Dr Cathryn Mainwaring, Susan Hendrickson, Rebecca Norton
Release Date: 26th Feb 2019
Functional decline or lack of improvement is common in older adults with severe #frailty undergoing #TAVR or #SAVR. The anticipation of health trajectories is needed to correctly design patient-tailored interventions@JAMAInternalMed#Heart #Geriatricshttps://t.co/0B7EkMBryx— Matteo Cesari (@macesari) February 5, 2019
A review article published in the BMJ on 31 January. Authored by Terence Quinn, Simon Mooijaart (Moy-yaart), Katie Gallacher, and Jennifer Burton. It’s called “Acute care assessment of older adults living with frailty.” I chose this because in it there’s a simple graphic to guide initial assessment of the frail older person when they present to acute care settings. To give a flavour of what is highlighted under four key domains you find, under history – medications, for physical exam – vision and hearing assessment, for psychiatric exam – a delirium screen, and for functional assessment – gait and balance. And what I liked about this is that around these four domains the authors have highlighted the knowledge about the home environment and caregivers as essential contextual information that should shape management of these individuals.
David Oliver piece
GSTT silver trauma course
King’s silver trauma course
Driving assessment: https://www.drivingmobility.org.uk/
Learning Objectives of Episode
To be able to describe the frequency and severity of trauma in older people
To understand that older people are at risk of traumatic events
To be able to assess the severity of injury in an older people
To understand the principles and importance of the completion of a secondary survey in older people
To understand that the mechanism of injury for major trauma in older people may require less of an impact than in younger people.
To understand that older people require input from a range or specialities when they have major trauma
Major Trauma is defined in the scientific literature using the Injury Severity Score (ISS), which assigns a value to injuries in different parts of the body and totals them to give a figure representing the severity of injury. An ISS greater than 15 is defined as Major Trauma
Major Trauma; “multiple serious injuries that could result in disability or death” – it makes no comment on the mechanism of the injury
The Silver Book, the British Geriatric Society guidelines for the emergency care of the older people, recognises the need for additional special considerations to be integrated with the ATLS approach in managing elderly trauma and endorses the view that geriatricians should receive training in the structured assessment of older people trauma, including hip fractures, head injury and polytrauma
Important to point out here I think that trauma can mean: Neurological injury, chest injury, skeletal injury or internal organ injury. It is not just broken bones. Assessment therefore as we shall see requires a range of professionals. We will not really talk too much about neck of femur fracture care as that is only one part of trauma and I will talk too long!
Key Points from Discussion
What is major trauma?
- Historically disease of young men and high energy transfer mechanisms of injury
- e.g. road traffic collisions, crush injuries, stabbings/shootings etc
- 1990 biggest major trauma group 0-24 years old (approx 40%)
- but…now- mean age of trauma patients is increasing
- The UK population is ageing – in the past 70 years ago, life expectancy in the United Kingdom has increased dramatically. Now just over 10% of Britons die before age 65, compared to nearly 50% when the NHS was founded in 1948.
- This increase has been greater than that predicted by population data alone, with the percentage of major trauma patients over 70 years old nearly tripling since 2005.
- In 1990, the mean age of the Major Trauma patient was 36.1 years, but by 2013 this had increased to 53.8 years
- the most common mechanism of injury is fall from standing height (i.e. low transfer mechanism of injury)
Trauma Audit and Research Network (TARN)
- In the late 1980s data showed that there was unnecessary mortality due to inadequacies in organisation and delivery of care – led to the development of TARN
- national organisation, collects data on trauma in the UK
- inputs- type of injury, physiological parameters, predicted survival, compared with actual outcomes
- now the largest trauma database in Europe
- really good source of lots of useful information/ research on trauma in the UK
- Trauma services are geographically organised into trauma networks
- In each region you will have;
- A Major Trauma unit (e.g Kings, St George’s, Brighton) with centralisation of expertise and specialties (such as neurosurgery, trauma surgery, cardiothoracics ect)
- Peripheral trauma units (e.g Frimley park, East Surrey Hospital) that provide care for most injured patients
- Trauma units will tend to see the less severely injured patients, whereas major trauma units will see those with more severe and multiple injuries
- Very similar process being set up in Scotland – 4 major centres
- Patient are seen initially in the prehospital setting (i.e. ambulance/ air ambulance)
- Prehospital practitioners use triage tools, transfer time and clinical judgement in order to decide whether the patient is transferred to a trauma unit or major trauma unit
- The major benefits of prehospital care are realized during the second phase of trauma (after the initial impact), when the timely provision of care can limit or halt the cascade of events that otherwise quickly leads to death or lifelong disability.Without prehospital care, many people who might otherwise survive their injuries may die at the scene or en route to the hospital. Most deaths in the first hours after injury are the result of airway compromise, respiratory failure or uncontrolled haemorrhage. All three of these conditions can be readily treated using basic first aid measures.
- Triage tools take in to account factors such as vital signs, anatomy of injury and mechanism of injury to guide decision making.
- Most tools also include special considerations for special patient groups such as pregnant women, the morbidly obese and older patients
- The idea is to get the right patient to the right place at the right time for the right treatment
- Current prehospital triage systems are not good at identifying older major trauma patients: just 17% of major patients older than 60 were triaged directly to MTCs by pre-hospital services, compared to 40% of those under 60 years old.
- This could be because much of the teaching on trauma triage emphasises the importance of mechanism of injury, aiming to identify high energy transfer mechanisms. However, this does not apply to older people, who can sustain serious injuries from relatively low energy transfer mechanisms.
- This lack of early identification means that initial treatment is more likely to be in a lower level Trauma Unit or District General Hospital, and to be undertaken by a more junior doctor.
- It also means older patients are less likely to be transferred to specialist care, and have longer times to both investigation and intervention – for instance, TARN has shown the elderly wait longer for a CT head following head injury, and have longer times to surgery across all body areas and categories.
- As expected, age has a profound impact on survival from Major Trauma: 12-month mortality in the over 75s is 40%, compared to 10% in the over 60s.
- Although older patients are more likely to die, those who survive do not have a larger incidence of disability compared to younger people.
Why is this though?
Thinking through the ABCDE of ATLS [NERD ALERT] – to talk through fairly swiftly – Must mention it comes from the excellent GeriEM course
- Difficult mouth opening (TMJ arthritis, general systemic stiffening),
- Cervical arthritis causes decreased mobility,
- Variable dentition and presence of dentures,
- Big tongue,
- Fragile easily damaged mucus membrane
- Decreased respiratory reserve (because of both normal aging and the effect of disease);
- Decreased chest wall musculature
- Fragile bones mean easily broken ribs
- Decreased chest wall compliance causing more devastating pulmonary contusion
- Age-related changes affecting cardiac output:
- Significant decrease in maximum heart rate ( = 220 – age),
- Decreased response to adrenergic catecholamines because of reduced responsiveness of membrane receptors
- “Stiff pump” causes diastolic dysfunction and therefore cardiac output much more dependent on atrial filing
- Non-age-related changes affecting cardiac output:
- Maximum rate further decreased by medications:
- Diuretic therapy can produce a chronically contracted vascular volume
- A common pitfall in assessment of Circulation is to interpret “normal” vital signs as representing normovolemia.
- Cerebral atrophy and increased CSF – brain is somewhat protected from contusion
- Resultant stretching of parasagittal bridging veins easily injured with minor impact and accel/decel injury
- Loss of intervertebral disks makes the vertebral column stiffer shifting force to the facets, ligaments and muscles and more fragile bone.
- Osteoarthritis and resultant spinal stenosis, segmental immobility and kyphosis
E (EXPOSURE / ENVIRONMENT)
- Age-related changes affecting injuries:
- Skin and connective tissue lose cells, strength and function – skin is thinner, less vascular and less able to thermoregulate
- More prone to:
- skin and soft tissue infection
- rapid development of pressure ulcers
Effects of comorbidities
- Comorbidity does have an adverse effect on outcome, but it is likely that other factors associated with age have a greater effect, in particular frailty.
- A single-centre study from 2015 looked at mortality based on location of injury (indoors vs outdoors) and found mortality significantly higher in indoor fallers.
- Other studies have shown significantly different characteristics between indoor and outdoor fallers with indoor fallers being frailer and more comorbid
- for instance the large MOBILIZE Boston Cohort study
- Here there were more wounds in outdoor falls but both groups had mobility and joint problems – hinting to the mechanism of the fall perhaps.
(Iain to mention here about ‘mechanical’ falls)
Chippendale T, Gentile PA, James MK, Melnic G. Indoor and outdoor falls among older adult trauma patients: A comparison of patient characteristics, associated factors and outcomes. Geriatr Gerontol Int 2017;17:905–12
- Both these studies have failed to show that increasing Injury Severity Score (ISS) significantly impacts on outcome – but our systems to look after older people with trauma as we shall see are often based around this score.
- Good outcomes are possible following Major Trauma in the elderly, and it appears possible to improve outcomes with coordinated and systematic approach, as has happened in neck of femur fractures (mortality has halved thanks to the NHFD)
- Surgeons in all specialties and anaesthetists are less reticent to operate on elderly patients than previously as outcomes continue to improve.
- For instance, severe open lower limb trauma is a complex injury in patients of all ages, and limb salvage may require free tissue transfer.
- Older people are more prone to this type of injury
- a recent single-centre study of management of severe open lower limb trauma in the elderly demonstrates positive outcomes: the group report only 7% mortality at 6 months, with the cause of death unrelated to injury in all of these patients.
- The study also reported positive patient reported outcome measure results, and clinical outcomes in keeping with and even better than those reported for other age groups (i.e., 1% flap failure rate and 150 days to bony union).
- It is vital to point out that this elderly patient group received expedient surgical intervention, indeed they received it as quickly as patients in younger age groups, and in keeping with national guidance.
Khadim MFK, Emam A, Wright TC, Chapman TW, Khan U. A Comparison Between The Major Trauma Centre Management Of Complex Open Lower Limb Fractures In Children And The Elderly. Injury 2019.
Systematic literature review and meta analysis of older patients with trauma (>65 but compared the >75 group to the 65-75 yrs)
Overall mortality rate among the geriatric population presenting with trauma is higher than among the adult trauma population. Patients older than 74 years experiencing traumatic injuries are at a higher risk for mortality than the younger geriatric group. However, the trauma-related mortality sustains the same rate after the age of 74 years without any further increase. Moreover, severe and extremely severe injuries and low systolic blood pressure at the presentation among geriatric trauma patients are significant risk factors for mortality.
A more recent large scale review:
- Older people appeared to have poorer postinjury functioning and HRQoL compared with younger adults or preinjury levels
- Poor preinjury function, pre-existing conditions and increasing age were associated with poorer outcomes, whereas preinjury-independent living was associated with better outcomes.
- but:… The studies were heterogeneous, limiting synthesis. There was a lack of evidence around the impact of injury on older people in terms of paid work and unpaid work. It was unclear if existing injury outcome guidelines are appropriate for older people.
- Older people do worse generally, and are often at increased risk of peri-procedural mortality, although this may relate to a more severe initial illness. However older people, who survive major trauma, have similar outcomes to their younger counterparts
- There is little seasonal variation in major trauma in older people.
- There was little variation in length of hospital stays across the adult age groups
- Comorbidity (as measured by the Charlson Comorbidity Index) has an adverse effect on outcome, but it is likely that other factors associated with age have a greater effect. Research is needed to determine the effect of frailty
- During the past few decades, research has shown that many injuries can be prevented or their severity reduced through the implementation of simple measures.
- Innovative solutions that engage different sectors of society have resulted in cost-effective interventions that can prevent injuries at work, at home and on the street.
- Examples include the use of motorcycle helmets and restraining systems, such as seat-belts and child restraints in cars.
detectors; and the installation of fencing around hazards such as wells or deep pools of water.
- Examples include the use of motorcycle helmets and restraining systems, such as seat-belts and child restraints in cars.
- Many of these strategies are highly cost effective.
- Motorbike helmets in UK – 1973
- Seat belt law in UK Motorbike helmets – 1983
- Seat bels in buses – all made after 2001
- Health and safety act – 1974
- Adult safeguarding – part of care act 2014
Where will we be in 2031?
Systems of care and care pathways in operation or in development
Midlands Silver Trauma Group
- The Midlands Silver Trauma Group was established in November 2016 by Midlands Critical Care and Trauma Networks to fulfil a number of aims
- To respond to issues emerging in management of elderly trauma
- To establish workable, evidence-based standards of care
- To expand their HECTOR (Heartlands Elderly Care Trauma & Ongoing Recovery) training programme from a regional to national initiative
- Their response to the problem of under-triage of elderly trauma patients was to implement a SIlver Trauma alert – a pre-alert issued to the receiving emergency department when an elderly patient was likely to need early intervention or access to imaging, but who may not always need a trauma team response.
Criteria for activation of the Silver Trauma Alert are:
- Age 65 or over
- Physiological parameters
- SBP <110mmHg with a significant injury
- Anatomical factors
- Injury to 2 or more body regions
- Suspected shaft of femur fracture
- Open fracture proximal to the wrists or ankles
- Mechanism factors
- Fall downstairs
- Direct conveyance to Major Trauma Centre if RTC or Pedestrian vs car mechanism
HECTOR – Dave Raven firstname.lastname@example.org
Knowledge Skills Framework (Suitable to support staff at the following levels:)
- Personal and People Development: Levels 1-3
- Service Improvement: Level 1 – 2
- Communication: Levels 3-4
Higher Specialist Training in Geriatric medicine
- 28. Diagnosis and Management of Acute Illness
- 30. Rehabilitation and Multidisciplinary Team Working
- 41. Orthogeriatrics
- 9. Recognises, assesses and initiates management of the acutely ill patient
- 16. Demonstrates understanding of the principles of health promotion and illness prevention
- 19. Makes patient safety a priority in clinical practice
Core surgical training
- Module 5 – Peri-operative care. The assessment and management of the surgical patient
- Module 6 – Assessment and management of patients with trauma (including the multiply injured patient)